Manual or electric pump? NikkiLeAnne 4 kids; Illinois 3589 posts
Mar 12th '17

Which do you feel works better? I'm so engorged but still not able to get much out with my electric pump. Was wondering if a manual pump would work better? 

Lyla & Maxwell's Mommy 3 kids; 2 angel babies; Wisconsin 1576 posts
Mar 12th '17

Electric. Are you using the 'let down' speed long enough?  It also helps to be near your baby and drink tons of water before. 

fluffyruffruff 5 kids; United States 4727 posts
Mar 12th '17

manual worked sooooo much better for me!

Britny Due August 10 (girl); 4 kids; 2 angel babies; ,, ,, United States 20895 posts
Mar 12th '17

Electric for me 

Their mama his wife 3 kids; 1 angel baby; Puerto Rico 7107 posts
Mar 12th '17

I've heard a lot of people react to a mania better.

ive never tried a manual bc these b**bs could hold 20 oz and I'm not trying to hurt my hand and sit there forever trying to pump.

3.24.10☀9.10.11☀12.13.14 Due July 17 (boy); TTC since Sep 2015; 3 kids; 2 angel babies; Oregon 3645 posts
Mar 12th '17

I exclusively pumped for a year with my third baby. I preferred an electric just for the ease of use, but I had to do a lot of squeezing and massaging of my breasts to get them to empty. So, almost hand expressing while using the electric. The first few months I was constantly getting clogged ducts too. 

Have Heart 2 kids; 2 angel babies; Western, NY, United States 9013 posts
Mar 12th '17

The manual was a nightmare. I tried once when we were at the fair, in a bathroom stall. and OMFG, never again.
My only issue with the manual was that my let down was too strong and would have needed one on each side. I was soaked, it was one of the worst experiences.

I'm faithful to my electric though, daily.
If you're too engorged where it's uncomfortable, hop in the shower and try hand expressing.