Reply

Cast Your Vote:

    • Spanking -- Votes: 59
    • Non-Spanking -- Votes: 43
spanking vs. non spanking KateMichelle 1 child; Michigan 109 posts
Jul 27th '13

Just want to know how many moms spank now-a-days. so let me no and comment it you wish. But keep it nice ladies

Amber ♡ 3 kids; Nunya, KS, United States 20467 posts
Jul 27th '13

I spank. I get lots of compliments from people who are always telling me how well my daughter behaves, too. She listens very, very well. I'm quite proud of my parenting thus far!



ETA: Although I try to do other things and not just jump to spanking. I tell her no, then time out, and spanking is the last result. She usually listens when I first tell her no though. Time outs & spankings aren't usually needed.

user banned 2 kids; Georgia 24891 posts
Jul 27th '13
Quoting MJ's Mommy♥:" I spank. I get lots of compliments from people who are always telling me how well my daughter behaves, ... [snip!] ... is the last result. She usually listens when I first tell her no though. Time outs & spankings aren't usually needed."


I don't spank, and get the same compliments.

*BrittNicole* Due April 11; TTC since Jul 2016; 2 kids; 1 angel baby; Ohio 4216 posts
status Jul 27th '13

I don't spank. I'm not saying its abuse but I was abused as a child and refuse to do that to my children! My parents took it too far. Smacking real hard excessively etc...

Amber ♡ 3 kids; Nunya, KS, United States 20467 posts
Jul 27th '13
Quoting A❤T=P&W:" I don't spank, and get the same compliments. "


Good for you. We all parent differently. I'm not saying that kids who aren't spanked are horrible kids, I'm just saying that's what works for my daughter.

Elle&Cole⛄️ 2 kids; 1 angel baby; Rio Rancho, NM, United States 32307 posts
Jul 27th '13

<blockquote><b>Quoting A❤T=P&W:</b>" I don't spank, and get the same compliments."</blockquote>




Yup.

user banned 2 kids; Georgia 24891 posts
Jul 27th '13

I couldn't image spanking my sweet innocent toddler :(




I am not completely opposed to spanking, but universal spanking for every infraction is not effective and will eventually loose it's ability to warrant results.

Boobo&bugs 2 kids; Simpsonville, South Carolina 8124 posts
Jul 27th '13

<blockquote><b>Quoting A❤T=P&W:</b>" I don't spank, and get the same compliments."</blockquote>




I don't either and get compliments to.

Amber ♡ 3 kids; Nunya, KS, United States 20467 posts
Jul 27th '13
Quoting A❤T=P&W:" I couldn't image spanking my sweet innocent toddler :( I am not completely opposed to spanking, but ... [snip!] ... but universal spanking for every infraction is not effective and will eventually loose it's ability to warrant results. "


Well, they aren't always sweet lol I never spank out of anger or over do it. Just 1-2 quick pops when it's really needed. *shrugs* no big deal to me.

Amber ♡ 3 kids; Nunya, KS, United States 20467 posts
Jul 27th '13
Quoting Tilda's Mommy:" <blockquote><b>Quoting A❤T=P&W:</b>" I don't spank, and get the same compliments."</blockquote> I don't either and get compliments to."


Once again, never said kids who aren't spanked are horrible kids.



Different things work for different kids. Each to their own.

. , Richmond, VA, United States 75118 posts
Jul 27th '13

I don't spank. I don't make it an option for myself so I have never done it.

user banned 2 kids; Georgia 24891 posts
Jul 27th '13
Quoting MJ's Mommy♥:" Well, they aren't always sweet lol I never spank out of anger or over do it. Just 1-2 quick pops when it's really needed. *shrugs* no big deal to me."


and when those 1-2 "pops" become ineffective?

user banned 2 kids; Bellingham, Washington 1616 posts
Jul 27th '13

<blockquote><b>Quoting MJ's Mommy♥:</b>" I spank. I get lots of compliments from people who are always telling me how well my daughter behaves, ... [snip!] ... is the last result. She usually listens when I first tell her no though. Time outs & spankings aren't usually needed."</blockquote>




Exactly this. Spanking may not work with every child but it does for mine. (My oldest). No matter where we go/who we are around, everyone is amazed at how well me 3 yr old and 1 1/2 yr old behave.

Amber ♡ 3 kids; Nunya, KS, United States 20467 posts
Jul 27th '13
Quoting A❤T=P&W:" and when those 1-2 "pops" become ineffective?"


Then I'd stop spanking altogether and try a different method of discipline.

Elle&Cole⛄️ 2 kids; 1 angel baby; Rio Rancho, NM, United States 32307 posts
Jul 27th '13

<blockquote><b>Quoting MJ's Mommy♥:</b>" Once again, never said kids who aren't spanked are horrible kids. Different things work for different kids. Each to their own."</blockquote>




I couldn't imagine hitting or "popping" Elliot, I'm not saying you're a bad parent or anything. I could just never do it